| Date | Home | Time/Results | Away | League | Season | Venue | Article |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
FC Buffalo  |  Dayton | Regular Season | 2024m | Preview | |||
Toledo  | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2024m | Preview | |||
FC Buffalo Women  |  Flower City | UWS | 2024w | Preview | |||
| FC Buffalo |  Cleveland Force | Regular Season | 2024m | Preview | |||
| FC Buffalo |  Kings Hammer | Regular Season | 2024m | Preview | |||
| FC Buffalo Women |  FC Berlin (Canada) | UWS | 2024w | Preview | |||
| Flower City | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2024w | Rochester Community Sports Complex Stadium | Preview | ||
| Dayton | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2024m | DOC Stadium | Preview | ||
Erie Women  | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2024w | Mercyhurst University | Preview | ||
| FC Buffalo |  Fort Wayne | Regular Season | 2024m | Preview | |||
| FC Buffalo Women | Erie Women | UWS | 2024w | Preview | |||
| Kings Hammer | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2024m | Xavier University | Preview | ||
| Cleveland Force | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2024m | Preview | |||
| Fort Wayne | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2024m | Preview | |||
Steel City  | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2024w | Founders Field | Preview | ||
| FC Buffalo | Cleveland Force | Regular Season | 2024m | Preview | |||
| FC Buffalo Women | Steel City | UWS | 2024w | Preview | |||
| Toledo | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2024m | Preview | |||
| FC Berlin (Canada) | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2024w | Coyer Field | Preview | ||
| FC Buffalo | Toledo | Regular Season | 2024m | Preview | |||
| FC Buffalo Women | 2 - 4 |  Lancaster Inferno | UWS, UWS Playoffs | 2023w | Williamsville South High School | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 1 - 0 |  Albany Rush | UWS Playoffs | 2023w | Williamsville South High School | Recap | |
| Toledo | 2 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2023m | Recap | ||
| Steel City | 1 - 3 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2023w | Founders Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 4 | Dayton | Regular Season | 2023m | Williamsville South High School | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 1 | Cleveland Force | Regular Season | 2023m | Williamsville South High School | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 4 - 1 | Erie Women | UWS | 2023w | Williamsville South High School | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | Kings Hammer | Regular Season | 2023m | Williamsville South High School | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 3 | Toledo | Regular Season | 2023m | Williamsville South High School | Recap | |
| FC Berlin (Canada) | 1 - 11 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2023w | Recap | ||
| Cleveland Force | 4 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2023m | DiSanto Field at Case Western | Recap | |
| Fort Wayne | 4 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2023m | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo Women | 3 - 0 | FC Berlin (Canada) | UWS | 2023w | Williamsville South High School | Recap | |
| Erie Women | 1 - 4 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2023w | Saxon Stadium - Mercyhurst University | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 4 | Toledo | Regular Season | 2023m | Williamsville South High School | Recap | |
| Dayton | 2 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2023m | DOC Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 10 - 1 | Flower City | UWS | 2023w | Williamsville South High School | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 2 - 0 | Steel City | UWS | 2023w | Williamsville South High School | Recap | |
| Kings Hammer | 1 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2023m | Xavier University | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 4 | Fort Wayne | Regular Season | 2023m | Williamsville South High School | Recap | |
| Flower City | 0 - 6 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2023w | Rochester Community Sports Complex Stadium | Recap | |
| Cleveland Force | 3 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2023m | DiSanto Field at Case Western | Recap | |
Calgary Foothills  | 4 - 1 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS Playoffs | 2022w | Lusitano Stadium | Recap | |
Coppermine  | 2 - 3 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS Playoffs | 2022w | Coppermine Norris Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 0 |  Cleveland SC | Regular Season | 2022m | Dobson Field | Recap | |
New England Mutiny  | 1 - 2 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS Playoffs | 2022w | Lusitano Stadium | Recap | |
Pittsburgh Women  | 1 - 4 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2022w | Founders Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 2 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2022m | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 2 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2022m | Saxon Stadium - Mercyhurst University | Recap | |
| Erie Women | 1 - 2 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2022w | Saxon Stadium - Mercyhurst University | Recap | |
| Pittsburgh Hotspurs | 1 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2022m | Founders Field | Recap | |
| Pittsburgh Women | 1 - 3 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2022w | Founders Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 0 - 0 |  Rochester Lady Lancers | UWS | 2022w | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 1 - 0 | FC Berlin (Canada) | UWS | 2022w | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| Cleveland SC | 3 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2022m | The George Finnie Stadium at Baldwin Wallace | Recap | |
Akron City  | 0 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2022m | St. Vincent-St. Mary High School of Akron | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 5 - 0 | Pittsburgh Women | UWS | 2022w | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 5 | Pittsburgh Hotspurs | Regular Season | 2022m | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| Rochester Lady Lancers | 2 - 0 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2022w | Aquinas Institute | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 1 | Akron City | Regular Season | 2022m | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 4 - 0 | Rochester Lady Lancers | UWS | 2022w | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 0 | Akron City | Regular Season | 2022m | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 2 - 2 | Erie Women | UWS | 2022w | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 2 | Pittsburgh Hotspurs | Regular Season | 2022m | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 0 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2022m | Saxon Stadium - Mercyhurst University | Recap | |
| FC Berlin (Canada) | 0 - 2 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2022w | Coyer Field | Recap | |
| Cleveland SC | 4 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2022m | The George Finnie Stadium at Baldwin Wallace | Recap | |
Genesee Community College  | FC Buffalo | Friendly | 2022m | Genesee Community College | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 7 - 0 | Cleveland SC | NISA Independent Cup | 2021m | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 0 |  Livonia City | NISA Independent Cup | 2021m | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 0 - 2 |  CT Fusion | UWS, UWS Playoffs | 2021w | Coyer Field | Recap | |
Syracuse FC  | 1 - 4 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2021m | Lazer Stadium at Onondaga Community College | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 3 - 2 | Lancaster Inferno | UWS, UWS Playoffs | 2021w | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
Detroit City FC  | 3 - 1 | FC Buffalo | NISA Independent Cup | 2021m | Keyworth Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 1 | Rochester Lancers | Regular Season | 2021m | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 4 - 0 | Rochester Lady Lancers | UWS | 2021w | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 0 - 1 |  Syracuse | UWS | 2021w | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 1 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2021m | Recap | ||
| Cleveland SC | 3 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2021m | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo Women | 5 - 1 | New England Mutiny | UWS | 2021w | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
Scorpions  | 5 - 2 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2021w | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 2 | Pittsburgh Hotspurs | Regular Season | 2021m | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
Worcester  | 1 - 2 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2021w | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 2 | Cleveland SC | Regular Season | 2021m | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 2 - 2 | Lancaster Inferno | UWS | 2021w | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Pittsburgh Hotspurs | 2 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2021m | Founders Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 5 - 1 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2021m | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo Women | 2 - 1 | Albany Rush | UWS | 2021w | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Syracuse | 0 - 1 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2021w | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 1 | Syracuse FC | Regular Season | 2021m | Dobson Field | Recap | |
| Rochester Lancers | 0 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2021m | Aquinas Institute | Recap | |
| Albany Rush | 2 - 3 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2021w | Recap | ||
| Rochester Lady Lancers | 1 - 2 | FC Buffalo Women | UWS | 2021w | Aquinas Institute | Recap | |
| Detroit City FC | 3 - 0 | FC Buffalo | NISA Independent Cup | 2020 | Keyworth Stadium | Recap | |
| Cleveland SC | 3 - 1 | FC Buffalo | NPSL Members Cup, NISA Independent Cup, Regular Season | 2020 | Hagerty Family Events Center | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 2 - 3 | FC Buffalo | NPSL Members Cup | 2020 | Erie Veterans Memorial Stadium | Recap | |
| Cleveland SC | 5 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2019 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 1 | Rochester Lancers | Regular Season | 2019 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 2 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2019 | Gannon University | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 3 | Cleveland SC | Regular Season | 2019 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Syracuse FC | 0 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2019 | Recap | ||
| Pittsburgh Hotspurs | 4 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2019 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 0 | Pittsburgh Hotspurs | Regular Season | 2019 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 0 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2019 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 5 - 0 | Syracuse FC | Regular Season | 2019 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 2 |  FC St. Pauli | Friendly | 2019 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Rochester Lancers | 4 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2019 | Recap | ||
Dortmund XI  | 1 - 5 | FC Buffalo | Friendly | 2019 | Brauksweg 15 | Recap | |
DSC Wanne-Eickel  | 2 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Friendly | 2019 | Mondpalast-Arena | Recap | |
| FC St. Pauli II | 4 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Friendly | 2019 | Hamburg, Germany | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 2 |  Monarcas Morelia Reserves | Friendly | 2019 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 4 - 1 |  North Mississauga SC | Friendly | 2018 | Sweet Home High School | Recap | |
Greater Binghamton FC  | 1 - 5 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2018 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 4 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2018 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
Fort Pitt Regiment  | 3 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2018 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 0 | Rochester Lancers | Regular Season | 2018 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Cleveland SC | 3 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2018 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 1 | Greater Binghamton FC | Regular Season | 2018 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Syracuse FC | 0 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2018 | Recap | ||
| Rochester Lancers | 2 - 4 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2018 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 0 | Cleveland SC | Regular Season | 2018 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 4 - 1 | Syracuse FC | Regular Season | 2018 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 4 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2018 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 2 | Fort Pitt Regiment | Regular Season | 2018 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 0 |  Daemen College | Friendly | 2018 | Sweet Home High School | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 1 |  AFC Cleveland | Regular Season | 2017 | Recap | ||
| Fort Pitt Regiment | 2 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2017 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 1 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2017 | Recap | ||
Dayton Dynamo  | 3 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2017 | Recap | ||
| Rochester Lancers | 2 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2017 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 0 | Fort Pitt Regiment | Regular Season | 2017 | Recap | ||
| Syracuse FC | 2 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2017 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 5 - 1 | Syracuse FC | Regular Season | 2017 | Recap | ||
| AFC Cleveland | 4 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2017 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 1 | Rochester Lancers | Regular Season | 2017 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 0 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2017 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 1 | Dayton Dynamo | Regular Season | 2017 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 0 |  Indy Eleven NPSL | Regular Season | 2016 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 3 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2016 | Gannon University | Recap | |
Rochester River DogZ FC  | 2 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2016 | Eunice Kennedy Shriver Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 0 | AFC Cleveland | Regular Season | 2016 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Indy Eleven NPSL | 3 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2016 | Grand Park | Recap | |
FC Indiana  | 0 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2016 | Legacy Sports Club | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 0 | FC Indiana | Regular Season | 2016 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 0 | Detroit City FC | Friendly | 2016 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Detroit City FC | 2 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Friendly | 2016 | Keyworth Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 1 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2016 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| AFC Cleveland | 2 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2016 | Stan Skoczen Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 1 | Rochester River DogZ FC | Regular Season | 2016 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 3 | AFC Cleveland | Regular Season | 2015 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Fort Pitt Regiment | 1 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2015 | Upper St. Clair High School | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 0 |  Lansing United | Regular Season | 2015 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 0 | Greater Binghamton FC | Friendly | 2015 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 2 - 4 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2015 | Gus Anderson Field at McDowell High School | Recap | |
| AFC Cleveland | 1 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2015 | Rocky River High School Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 0 | Fort Pitt Regiment | Regular Season | 2015 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
Michigan Stars FC  | 1 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2015 | Wisner Stadium | Recap | |
Rochester Rhinos  | 3 - 0 | FC Buffalo | 2015 | Rochester Community Sports Complex Stadium | Recap | ||
| Greater Binghamton FC | 1 - 1 | FC Buffalo | 2015 | Greater Binghamton Sports Complex | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 2 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2015 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
Indiana Fire  | 2 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2015 | Park Tudor High School | Recap | |
| FC Indiana | 2 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2015 | Legacy Sports Club | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 1 | Detroit City FC | Regular Season | 2015 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 1 |  Cincinnati Saints | Regular Season | 2015 | Howe Field at Hamburg High School | Recap | |
| Genesee Community College | 1 - 3 | FC Buffalo | 2015 | Genesee Community College | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 5 - 1 | Michigan Stars FC | Regular Season | 2014 | Demske Sports Complex at Canisius College | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 1 | Detroit City FC | Regular Season | 2014 | Demske Sports Complex at Canisius College | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 3 | Fort Pitt Regiment | Regular Season | 2014 | Demske Sports Complex at Canisius College | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 2 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2014 | Gannon University | Recap | |
| Lansing United | 2 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2014 | East Lansing Soccer Complex | Recap | |
| AFC Cleveland | 2 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2014 | DiSanto Field at Case Western | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 4 | Fort Pitt Regiment | Regular Season | 2014 | Demske Sports Complex at Canisius College | Recap | |
| Fort Pitt Regiment | 5 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2014 | Birko Memorial Stadium | Recap | |
| Cincinnati Saints | 0 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2014 | Stargel Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 0 | AFC Cleveland | Regular Season | 2014 | Demske Sports Complex at Canisius College | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 2 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2014 | Demske Sports Complex at Canisius College | Recap | |
| Indiana Fire | 2 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2014 | Westfield High School | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 1 | AFC Cleveland | Regular Season | 2014 | Demske Sports Complex at Canisius College | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 2 - 4 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2014 | Penn State Behrend - Junker Center | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 5 | Erie Commodores FC | Playoffs | 2013 | Cass Tech High School | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 2 | Detroit City FC | Regular Season | 2013 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
Zanesville Athletic FC  | 0 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2013 | Maysville Athletic Complex | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 3 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2013 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Detroit City FC | 4 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2013 | Cass Tech High School | Recap | |
FC Sparta Michigan  | 0 - 4 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2013 | Hurley Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 0 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2013 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 2 | AFC Cleveland | Regular Season | 2013 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Zanesville Athletic FC | 0 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2013 | Maysville Athletic Complex | Recap | |
| AFC Cleveland | 0 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2013 | Krenzler Field | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 1 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2013 | Gannon University | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 1 | FC Sparta Michigan | Regular Season | 2013 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 1 | Zanesville Athletic FC | Regular Season | 2013 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| AFC Cleveland | 3 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2012 | Byers Field | Recap | |
| Greater Binghamton FC | 4 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2012 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 4 | Detroit City FC | Regular Season | 2012 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 1 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2012 | Gannon University | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 1 | Greater Binghamton FC | Regular Season | 2012 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Detroit City FC | 3 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2012 | Cass Tech High School | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 3 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2012 | Gannon University | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 2 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2012 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 1 | Greater Binghamton FC | Regular Season | 2012 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 2 | AFC Cleveland | Regular Season | 2012 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| AFC Cleveland | 4 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2012 | Byers Field | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 0 | Detroit City FC | Regular Season | 2012 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Rochester Rhinos | 1 - 0 | FC Buffalo | 2012 | Rochester Community Sports Complex Stadium | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 0 |  New Jersey Blaze | Regular Season | 2011 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 7 - 0 |  Buxmont Torch | Regular Season | 2011 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 4 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2011 | Recap | ||
FC Reading Revolution  | 1 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2011 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 5 - 1 |  Bedlington Terriers FC | 2011 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | ||
Pocono Snow  | 0 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2011 | Recap | ||
FC Sonic Lehigh Valley  | 3 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2011 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 1 | FC Sonic Lehigh Valley | Regular Season | 2011 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| New Jersey Blaze | 1 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2011 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 2 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2011 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 0 | Pocono Snow | Regular Season | 2011 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Buxmont Torch | 1 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2011 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 1 - 2 | FC Reading Revolution | Regular Season | 2011 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
Brooklyn Italians  | 1 - 0 | FC Buffalo | US Open Cup | 2011 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 3 - 0 | FC Reading Revolution | Regular Season | 2010 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
TSC Maryland Red Devils  | 2 - 3 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2010 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 7 - 1 | TSC Maryland Red Devils | Regular Season | 2010 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Erie Commodores FC | 2 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2010 | Gannon University | Recap | |
| New Jersey Blaze | 0 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2010 | Recap | ||
| FC Reading Revolution | 4 - 2 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2010 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 0 | Pocono Snow | Regular Season | 2010 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 0 | FC Sonic Lehigh Valley | Regular Season | 2010 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Pocono Snow | 1 - 1 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2010 | Recap | ||
| FC Sonic Lehigh Valley | 1 - 0 | FC Buffalo | Regular Season | 2010 | Recap | ||
| FC Buffalo | 2 - 0 | New Jersey Blaze | Regular Season | 2010 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| FC Buffalo | 0 - 3 | Erie Commodores FC | Regular Season | 2010 | Robert E. Rich All-High Stadium | Recap | |
| Rochester Rhinos | 2 - 0 | FC Buffalo | 2010 | Rochester Community Sports Complex Stadium | Recap |
Recent Comments